← All owner guides

Owner guide · 7 min read

Why Does My Website Say Not Secure?

Your browser says Not Secure when a page loads without HTTPS, the encryption that keeps what visitors type private. The usual causes are a missing or expired certificate, an old http:// address that doesn't forward, or one insecure image or form on the page. Certificates are free on most hosts, so the fix is usually quick.

KC Hansen

Published October 27, 2026

98%

of 409 Utah trade websites had working HTTPS (Oct 2026)

35%

send 3 or more of 5 basic security settings with their pages

38%

have the email records that stop others faking their address

Chrome and other browsers show “Not secure” when a page loads without HTTPS, the encryption that stops anyone between your visitor and your website from reading or changing what’s sent. Google’s own help page puts it simply: the site isn’t using a private connection, and the fix is for the site owner to switch on HTTPS (Chrome Help). For most businesses that’s a quick, free fix. The good news from our research: almost every Utah trade website has the padlock. The bad news: most stop there.

What does “Not secure” actually mean?

It means the page wasn’t loaded over an encrypted connection. Anything a visitor types into it, like a name, phone number or address on your quote form, could in principle be read or changed on its way to you. On public Wi-Fi at a coffee shop, that isn’t just theory.

It doesn’t mean your site has been hacked. It’s a warning about the connection, not proof of a break-in. But your customers can’t tell the difference, and a warning next to your name in the address bar makes people hesitate right when you want them to call.

The four usual causes and how to fix each

What’s wrongHow you’d noticeThe fix
No certificate at allEvery page says Not secureTurn on the free certificate in your host or builder settings
The certificate expiredA full-page warning, often “Your connection is not private”Renew it, and turn on automatic renewal
The http:// version doesn’t forwardThe warning shows only when someone types or clicks an old http:// linkSet every version of your address to forward to https://
Mixed contentOnly one page shows the warning, or the padlock has a warning signChange the image, script or form on that page from http:// to https://

Free certificates are normal now. Let’s Encrypt, a nonprofit, gives them away for free and serves more than 700 million websites (Let’s Encrypt). Most hosts and builders, including WordPress hosts, Wix, Squarespace and GoDaddy, include one and renew it for you.

Tip: type your address with http:// in front, then without www, then with it. Every version should land on the same https:// address. If any of them shows a warning or a different page, that’s the one to fix.

How many Utah trade websites get this right?

Almost all of them get the padlock. Far fewer get the rest. In October 2026 we checked the websites of 409 independent Utah trade businesses, taken from Google’s map results for 10 trades across Provo, Salt Lake City, Layton, Lehi and Sandy.

Most Utah trade sites have the padlock. Fewer have the rest.

Share of 409 independent Utah trade websites passing each security check.

Working HTTPS with a valid certificate98%
No out-of-date software showing98%
Every address version ends at one place86%
Contact form has spam protection60%
Email protection records (SPF + DMARC)38%
3+ of 5 security settings sent35%
Source: YourProject.ai scan of 409 independent Utah trade websites, October 21, 2026. Spam protection is out of the 334 sites with a form. "Out-of-date software" covers what we could detect from outside (WordPress and jQuery versions).

Before that, some sites weren’t working at all. Google’s map results linked to 472 trade business websites. 24 of them, about 5%, had no working website behind the link: 12 had a domain that was gone or a certificate error, and 12 were parked, expired, broken or taken over by spam. Those businesses are sending customers from Google straight to an error page.

The padlock is nearly universal. 400 of the 409 working sites (98%) loaded over HTTPS with a valid certificate, and only 3 had a certificate within two weeks of expiring.

One address, many doors. 14% of sites didn’t send every version of their address (http, https, with and without www) to the same place. Usually that means one version shows a warning, an error or a duplicate copy of the site.

The protection most sites skip

A padlock protects the connection. A few more settings protect the page and your name.

Security settings sent with each page. Five settings, sent quietly with every page, tell the browser to always use HTTPS, not to let other sites frame your page, not to guess file types, what’s allowed to run, and how much to share when someone clicks away. The OWASP Foundation, the web’s best-known security nonprofit, recommends all of them (OWASP). Most Utah trade sites send almost none:

Most sites send few or none of the five basic security settings

Number of 409 Utah trade websites by how many of 5 settings they send (HSTS, CSP, nosniff, frame, referrer).

None148 (36%)
175 (18%)
245 (11%)
361 (15%)
465 (16%)
All 515 (4%)
Source: YourProject.ai scan, October 21, 2026. Settings read from each homepage's response.

This depends heavily on the platform, because owners rarely set these themselves. Squarespace sent 3 or more on 14 of its 17 sites. WordPress did on 19% (28 of 148), GoHighLevel on 6 of 33, and Wix on 1 of 29.

Email protection records. Two short records on your domain, called SPF and DMARC, tell email providers which servers may send mail as [email protected]. Without them, it’s easier for a scammer to send an invoice that looks like it came from you, and your own quotes are more likely to land in spam. Gmail now requires these from bulk senders and expects at least SPF or DKIM from everyone (Google Workspace Admin Help). Only 38% of the Utah trade domains we checked had both SPF and DMARC.

Form spam protection. Of the 334 sites with a contact form, 40% had no spam protection we could detect. Unprotected forms fill up with junk, and real requests get buried or ignored.

Domain renewal. 19 of 399 domains we could check (5%) were within 60 days of expiring. An expired domain takes your website and your email down at the same time.

Does Not Secure hurt your Google ranking?

Slightly, and that’s not the main reason to fix it. Google announced HTTPS as a ranking signal in 2014, and said at the time it was “a very lightweight signal,” affecting fewer than 1% of searches (Google Search Central Blog). The bigger cost is trust. A visitor deciding between three roofers isn’t going to pick the one whose site carries a warning label.

What to do this week

  1. Check the padlock on your homepage, your contact page and one service page.
  2. Test every version of your address (with http://, without www) and make sure all of them end at the same https:// page.
  3. Turn on auto-renew for your domain and your certificate, and check the card on file hasn’t expired.
  4. Send yourself a test from your contact form, then ask your web person whether it has spam protection.
  5. Ask whoever handles your email whether your domain has SPF and DMARC records. It’s a ten-minute job for them.
  6. Ask when the site’s software was last updated. Out-of-date plugins and themes are a well-known weak spot.

If you’d like to see how your hosting choice plays into this, our guide on whether it matters where your site is hosted covers it, and does my website need a privacy policy? covers the forms side.

How we handle this for you

Every site we build is hosted on Amazon Web Services with HTTPS everywhere and security headers, the protective settings described above, kept up to date as part of Care, our $99-a-month plan. Forms have spam protection.

Your domain is registered in your name, in your own account, and you pay its yearly renewal, so turn on auto-renew there. The build is $5,000, one time, and you see your new site working before you pay anything. You can stop the monthly plan anytime and keep everything.

See what we build and what it costs, look at sites we’ve built, or apply in about two minutes.

How we measured

  • Who: the websites of 409 independent Utah trade businesses, taken in order from Google’s local map results for 10 trades in Provo, Salt Lake City and Layton (plus Lehi and Sandy for some trades). 472 sites were linked from those results; broken, parked and blocked sites were counted separately and not scored; national franchise sites were left out.
  • When: October 21, 2026.
  • How: each site was loaded over https:// and http://, with and without www. We read the certificate, the security settings sent with the homepage, the visible software versions, the domain’s public DNS records (SPF, DMARC) and its registration expiry date. We didn’t test for break-ins or try to get past any protection, and we didn’t look at anything that isn’t public.
  • Limits: a check from the outside can’t see everything; a site can pass all of these and still have weak passwords or an old plugin we can’t detect. These are a floor, not a full security audit.
  • Who we are: we build websites for local businesses, so we have a stake in this topic. We don’t name any business.

Sites we've built

Real sites we built for local businesses. See all our work →

Five-minute security check

0 / 6

Tap to tick. Your ticks stay on this device.

Questions

Asked constantly. Answered honestly.

Does an SSL certificate cost money? +

Usually not. Let's Encrypt gives certificates away free, and most hosts and website builders include one and renew it automatically. Paid certificates exist, but a small business website almost never needs one.

My site shows a padlock. Is it secure now? +

The padlock means the connection is encrypted. That's the minimum. A secure site also keeps its software up to date, sends a few protective settings with every page, protects its forms from spam, and has a domain that won't lapse.

Does Not Secure hurt my Google ranking? +

Google has used HTTPS as a ranking signal since 2014, but called it very lightweight. The bigger cost is people: a warning next to your name in the address bar makes visitors think twice before typing their phone number.

Why does it only say Not Secure on some pages? +

Usually one page still loads an image, script or form over plain http://, or one old link points to the http:// version of your site. Open the page, check the address bar, and look for anything on it that starts with http:// instead of https://.

$5,000 for your website + from $99/mo after. See it before you pay.

See your new site free
KC Hansen

founded YourProject.ai in Lehi, where we build websites for local businesses. His whole career in IT (security, cloud, DevOps) means every site is fast, secure and built right, and kept up to date every month. More about KC and every guide →